The Panel noted the following:

REQUESTS FOR ENFORCEMENT/PROSECUTION ACTION

(a)       31 Westgate, Shipley                                                                    Shipley

Unauthorised externally mounted roller shutters - 16/01019/ENFUNA.

(b)       6 Edward Street, Saltaire                                                              Shipley

Unauthorised change of use from residential to a mixed use including both residential and retail use for the operation of a bakery - 15/00989/ENFCOU.

(c)        Land to the East of Long Gate, Sutton in Craven,                 Worth

            Oakworth, Keighley                                                                       Valley

Unauthorised development – 17/00053/ENFUNA

DECISIONS MADE BY THE SECRETARY OF STATE

APPEAL ALLOWED

(d)       High Binns, Height Lane, Oxenhope, Keighley                     Worth

                                                                                                                        Valley

Barn conversion an ancillary to dwelling, minor extension of domestic curtilage, engineering works to create an underground car park within established curtilage and deposit of excavated material on adjacent field – Case No: 16/01852/FUL.

Appeal Ref: 16/00127/APPFL2.

APPEALS DISMISSED

(e)       1 Thorn Gate, Whalley Lane, Denholme, Bradford               Bingley

                                                                                                                        Rural

Change of use of agricultural building and land to residential use (C3) and associated external alterations – Case No: 16/04729/PAR.

Appeal ref:  16/00128/APPPAR.

(f)        10 The Hallows, Keighley                                                                        Keighley

                                                                                                                        Central

Appeal against Enforcement Notice – Case No:  15/00609/ENFUNA.

Appeal Ref: 16/00076/APPENF

(g)       Broad View, Hob Cote Lane, Oakworth, Keighley                Worth

                                                                                                                        Valley

Demolition of garden sheds and replacement with new garden store building – Case No: 16/05490/HOU.

Appeal Ref:  17/00002/APPHOU.

(h)       Fair Deal Beds, Unit 2, Back Prospect Place, Keighley       Keighley

                                                                                                                        Central

Appeal against Enforcement Notice – Case No: 12/00451/ENFUNA.

Appeal Ref:  16/00070/APPENF.

Action:  Strategic Director, Place